Douglas Fir vs Cedar: Which One Is Right for You?

We research in-depth and provide unbiased reviews and recommendations on the best products. We strive to give you the most accurate information. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

There are a lot of choices to make when it comes to selecting the right type of wood for your project. Two of the most popular options are Douglas fir and cedar. Both kinds of wood have their pros and cons, so how do you decide which is right for you? In this blog post, we’ll take a look at the differences between Douglas fir and cedar, and help you figure out which one is best suited for your needs.

What is Douglas Fir lumber?

Douglas fir lumber is a popular choice for construction and home projects due to its strength and durability. Although it is sometimes confused with cedar, douglas fir is a different species of tree. Both douglas fir and cedar are members of the pine family, but douglas fir is much larger, with a trunk that can be up to six feet in diameter.

The wood of a douglas fir tree is also much denser than cedar, making it more resistant to rot and insect damage. Douglas fir lumber is an excellent choice for both indoor and outdoor projects and can provide many years of use with proper care.

douglas fir

What is Cedar lumber?

Cedar is a type of softwood that is light in weight and has a very fine grain. It is also naturally resistant to rot, decay, and insect damage. Cedar is often used for outdoor projects such as decks, fences, and siding due to its durability. It is also a popular choice for indoor projects such as paneling, cabinets, and trim.

Cedar is a softer wood than douglas fir, which means it is easier to work with using hand tools. It also stains and paints well, giving you a lot of options for finishing your project. Cedar is typically more expensive than douglas fir, but it is widely available and easy to find.

Comparing Douglas Fir vs Cedar lumber

When it comes to lumber, there are a few different types of wood that you might come across. Two of the most popular types are Douglas Fir and Cedar. Both have their own unique features and benefits, so it can be difficult to decide which one is right for your project. Let’s compare them with the following factors:

The Appearance of Douglas Fir and Cedar

Douglas Fir lumber is typically light brown or a reddish-brown, with a straight grain and few knots. Cedar lumber is reddish, with a very distinct grain pattern. Both kinds of wood are relatively easy to stain, so you can match the color of your project to your liking.

Strength of Douglas Fir and Cedar

When it comes to the strength of Douglas Fir and Cedar, Douglas Fir is usually the winner. It is stronger and more durable than Cedar, meaning that it can withstand more wear and tear. Douglas Fir lumber is strong and stiff, making it ideal for framing and construction. Cedar lumber is also strong and stiff but is lighter weight than Douglas Fir. If you are looking for a lumber that will hold up well over time, Douglas Fir is a good option.

cedar wood

The Durability of Douglas Fir and Cedar

When it comes to the durability of Douglas Fir and Cedar, there is no clear winner. Both kinds of wood are incredibly sturdy and resistant to damage, making them perfect for use in outdoor projects. Douglas Fir is slightly more resistant to pests and decay, but Cedar is more environmentally friendly, because it is a natural insect repellent. Cedar is also more resistant to fire, making it the ideal choice for use in fire pits or outdoor kitchens.

Pest Resistance Douglas Fir and Cedar

Douglas Fir lumber is naturally resistant to pests, making it ideal for outdoor projects. Cedar lumber is also resistant to pests but is not as resistant as Douglas Fir.

Environmental Friendliness of Douglas Fir and Cedar

Douglas Fir lumber is a sustainable resource and is biodegradable. Cedar lumber is also a sustainable resource but is not as biodegradable as Douglas Fir.

Cost of Douglas Fir and Cedar

When it comes to cost, Douglas Fir is typically a little bit cheaper than Cedar. However, the difference is not very significant, so it depends on the particular project you are working on. If you are looking for an affordable option that still has good quality, Douglas Fir is a good choice.

Ease of Working With Douglas Fir and Cedar

Douglas Fir lumber is easy to work with, and nails and screws easily. Cedar lumber is also easy to work with, but is more likely to split than Douglas Fir.

When it comes to choosing between Douglas Fir and Cedar Lumber, it depends on the particular project you are working on. Both types of wood have their unique benefits, so it is important to choose the one that is best suited for your needs. If you are looking for strong and durable lumber, Douglas Fir is a good choice.

When not to use Douglas Fir or Cedar lumber

You should not use Douglas Fir or Cedar lumber:

  • If you are building a structure that needs to be fire-resistant, such as a garage or a shed, you will want to use a different type of lumber. Douglas Fir and Cedar are both flammable.
  • If you are constructing an outdoor deck or patio, you will want to use a different type of lumber. Douglas Fir and Cedar are both susceptible to rot and insect damage.
  • If you are looking for very strong lumber, Douglas Fir is a better choice than Cedar. Cedar is softer and not as strong.
  • If you are looking for environmentally friendly lumber, Douglas Fir is a better choice than Cedar. Cedar is not as eco-friendly because it is not as renewable.

Overall, Douglas Fir is the better choice of lumber between the two. It is more fire-resistant, stronger, and more environmentally friendly than Cedar. However, Cedar is more pest-resistant and easier to work with. The decision of which lumber to use depends on the particular project you are working on.

Alternatives to using Douglas Fir or Cedar lumber

There are many reasons why douglas fir and cedar lumber are popular choices for construction and other projects. Both kinds of wood are strong and durable, and they have a natural resistance to rot and insect damage. However, douglas fir and cedar are also two of the most expensive woods available, and they can be difficult to find in some areas.

As a result, many homeowners and builders are looking for alternatives to douglas fir and cedar. These woods are more affordable than douglas fir and cedar, and they can be just as strong and durable. In addition, these are more widely available, making them easy to find in most parts of the country. Some of the most popular options include:

Hemlock

Hemlock is a type of wood that is growing in popularity as an alternative to douglas fir and cedar. Hemlock is strong and durable, and it has a natural resistance to rot and insect damage. In addition, hemlock is more affordable than douglas fir and cedar, and it can be just as strong and durable. In addition, hemlock is more widely available, making it easy to find in most parts of the country.

Pine

Pine is another popular alternative to douglas fir and cedar. Pine is a softer wood, but it is still strong and durable. Pine has a natural resistance to rot and insect damage, and it is more affordable than douglas fir and cedar. In addition, pine is more widely available, making it easy to find in most parts of the country.

Oak

Oak is another popular alternative to douglas fir and cedar. Oak is a hardwood, and it is very strong and durable. Oak has a natural resistance to rot and insect damage, and it is more affordable than douglas fir and cedar. In addition, oak is more widely available, making it easy to find in most parts of the country.

Maple

Maple is another popular alternative to douglas fir and cedar. Maple is a hardwood, and it is very strong and durable. Maple has a natural resistance to rot and insect damage, and it is more affordable than douglas fir and cedar. In addition, maple is more widely available, making it easy to find in most parts of the country.

douglas fir vs cedar

Cherry

Douglas Fir and Cedar are both popular types of lumber, but if you’re looking for an alternative, Cherry might be a good option.

Cherry is another popular alternative to douglas fir and cedar. It is a hardwood that is strong and durable, and it also has a beautiful appearance. It is very strong and durable. In addition, cherry is more widely available, making it easy to find in most parts of the country. It is resistant to pests and decay, and it is environmentally friendly.

Cherry is also relatively easy to work with, and it is not as expensive as some other hardwoods. Keep in mind, however, that Cherry is not as strong as Douglas Fir or Cedar, so it might not be the best choice for certain projects.

Spruce

Spruce is a type of softwood that is commonly used in construction projects. It has a straight grain and is relatively easy to work with. Spruce is also a lightweight wood, which makes it easy to transport and work with. Spruce is also resistant to rot and decay, making it a durable option for your project.

If you’re looking for an environmentally friendly option, Spruce is a good choice because it is a renewable resource. However, it is still a strong enough wood for most construction projects. Spruce is also not as resistant to pests and insects as Douglas Fir and Cedar.

Redwood

While both Douglas Fir and Cedar are great options for lumber, they might not be the best choice for every project. If you’re looking for an alternative to these woods, Redwood might be a better option. Redwood is a type of wood that is native to California, and it is known for its strength, durability, and pest resistance.

Redwood is also a more environmentally friendly option than Douglas Fir and Cedar, as it is sourced from sustainably managed forests. Redwood is also typically cheaper than both Douglas Fir and Cedar, making it a great option if you’re working with a tight budget. One downside of Redwood is that it can be difficult to work with, so it might not be the best choice if you’re a beginner.

Conclusion

In conclusion, when it comes to lumber, Douglas Fir and Cedar are both great options. They have different benefits and drawbacks, so it is important to consider what you will be using the wood for before making a decision. Douglas Fir is strong and durable, resistant to pests, environmentally friendly, and relatively easy to work with. Cedar is also strong and durable but is more resistant to rot and decay. It is also more expensive than Douglas Fir.

Both kinds of wood are great for different reasons making them both a top choice depending on the project you are working on. If you need a more durable and longer-lasting wood then douglas fir is the better option. If you are looking for wood that is resistant to rot and decay then cedar is the better option. No matter what project you are working on, douglas fir and cedar woods are great choices.

FAQs

Is Douglas fir good for outdoor use?

Douglas Fir is a great choice for outdoor use because it is resistant to decay and insects. Cedar is also a good choice for outdoor use, but it is not as resistant to decay and insects as Douglas Fir. Douglas fir is a great choice for outdoor projects, as it is resistant to decay, weathering, and insects. Cedar is also a good choice for outdoor projects, as it is resistant to decay and weathering.

How much does the douglas fir vs cedar cost?

The cost of douglas fir vs cedar varies depending on the grade and thickness of the wood. Douglas Fir is generally cheaper than Cedar, but it is not as strong or durable. Cedar is more expensive, but it is stronger and more resilient to pests.

Does Douglas’s fir need to be sealed?

Douglas fir does not need to be sealed to protect it from the elements. Cedar, on the other hand, does require a sealant to protect it from moisture and pests. Douglas fir is also a little bit stronger and more durable than cedar, making it a better choice for projects that will be exposed to the

Douglas fir vs Cedar: Which one is better for furniture?

When it comes to furniture, Douglas Fir is a better option than Cedar. Cedar is not as strong as Douglas Fir, so it is not as suitable for furniture that will be used frequently. Douglas Fir is also more durable than Cedar, and it is pest resistant. Cedar is more environmentally friendly than Douglas Fir, but it is also more expensive. Douglas Fir is easier to work with than Cedar. Overall, Douglas Fir is the better option for furniture.

Why trust Handyman.Guide?

s written by Itamar Ben-Dor, who has 25 years of experience in renovations, carpentry, locks, creation, landscaping, painting, furniture construction, and furniture renovation, works with concrete, plumbing, door repair, and more.

Itamar Ben-Dor has been in the home improvement business for over 25 years. Itamar Ben-Dor is a jack of all trades. He's worked in the renovation field for years, doing everything from locksmithing to carpentry. He's a small repairs specialist. But his true passion lies in furniture construction and renovation - he loves seeing old pieces come back to life with some new woodwork or a fresh coat of paint.

He has taken courses on many topics in these fields at professional colleges in Israel. Over the years, Itamar has also become quite skilled in gardening, carpentry, and renovations. He's worked on projects of all sizes, from massive renovations to small repairs. No job is too big or too small for him!


Disclosure: handyman.guide participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for publishers to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

HandyMan.Guide
Logo